https://declassified.library.utoronto.ca/files/original/b607bc929e8ccca2d2bae7fafa2d7a23.pdf 144b4ed90d00aa2820247497ae3aaeb3 PDF Text Text / CONSEIL DE L'ATLANTIQUE NORD NORTH ATLANTIC COUNCIL csc/JS ".::•.*:••••: * irfrWZ:ZY :; pLA1RE -WtVf - "* ixn m^ A* jfib / EXEM COPY yj^jjy^ 9 RUA— ORIGINAL: ENGLISH CH&'O™ 23rd April 71964 ' .^P" .•,..:: . '" '"" . HATO SECRET A-"-.. -'• WORKING PAPER ; "'• AC/Tg^-wp^ , • •:'""c,,~ WORKING :GROUP 'ON A JRAFT AGREEMENT FOR CO-OPERATION •'•"'•"• REGARDING ATOMIC INFORMATlof ' ™~~ SECOND REVISION OF DRAFT AGREEMENT - . • . — - p ~ ' " \ " " i ' " ' 7 . ' ~: i V m 1 1 m I I . r • • i i i m • i Note by the Chairman ' P • - Members -of the Working Group will recall that, at their last meeting on 16th-18th October, 1963 It was agreed that the Group would reconvene once the French and United States Delegations had''reached-agreement on* the points at issue betv/een them« " 2-«A; Sllch; ah understanding has now been achieved and the attached document represents a draft agreed jointly by the French and United States Delegations. 3* -The passages in square brackets denote those pointsP on which, as was indicated in AG/228-WP/l, other delegation's still have certain reserves* These are: (a) In the Agreement: (I) - Articles I and-IV(1): The Canadian Delegation suggests that the application of future United States legislation could be provided for by the insertion of the bracketed phrase in Article I, Article IV(1) could then be deleted. . (ii) Article VI1(1): New sub-article proposed by the f United States concerning patents rights, (iii) Article VIII.s New article proposed by the Canadian Delegation to clarify the situation regarding bilateral agreements. (iv) Article X(2): New sub-article to cover the possibility of future accessions to the North Atlantic Treaty. (v) Article X(3)i The French Delegation wonders whether the order of the bracketed phrase should not be reversed, or "Council" substituted for "Treaty Organization"* NATO SECRET �NAT0_J3ECRET AC7228~¥P72 -2- —-""- (vi) (b) - * ^ Article X.IX paragraph 1: The United Kingdom DeTegatTon wishes the.security provisions of the 1955 Agreement.to-continue-to apply to information communicated uhd-er that-Agreement. In the^ Technical Annex: . •A'•-•-•' " - "'- ••''••' Pr e amble: At the last meeting of the Working- - Group", the United States Delegation undertook to refer back to Its Authorities on this redraft of the Preamble,' which, in the opinion of the ..... ... United Kingdom Delegation-in particular,-would avoid any implication that the Anhe'x constituted a separate Agreement. (c) In the Security Annex: (i) (ii) Section IV, paragraph D and Section VI, paragraph At.2 ?Dhe German. DeTegatioh wishes "no* reference to be made, in accountability records and reports, to the use made of the information. Section IV, paragraph E.l: The German'Delegation wishes to ensure that a certain number of translations may be made without prior United States approval, 4. This new draft will be discussed at a meeting of the Working Group to be held on Monday 4th May, 1964 at 10 a.nu and .3. p.m. • (Signed) COLERIDGE 0TAN/NAT0, Paris, XVIe. NATO SECRET �NATO SECRET ' , AC/228-WP/2 • 3- •= AGREEMENT' BETWEEN THE PARTIES TO THE NORTH ATLANTIC TREATY POP OO-OPERATION REGARDING ATOMIC INFORMATION PREAMBLE The Parties to the North Atlantic Treaty, sighed at Washington on 4th April, 1949, Recognising that their mutual security and defence requires that they be prepared to. meet the contingencies of atomic warfare, and Recognising that their common interest will be advanced by making, available to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization and its member states information pertinent thereto, and Taking into consideration the United States. Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended, which was prepared with.these purposes ±n mind, Acting on their own behalf and .on behalf.of the North Atlantic Treaty •Organization, • Agree as follows: 'P.' ''•'.••' 1 'ARTICLE: I •v"yy.7 y -"'' , y',. .77 In accordance with and subject to the requirements oT.the United States Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended, /and such o1;her legislation as may modify, supplement-or replace this .: Act in the future/, the Government of. the United States of America will, while the North Atlantic Treaty Organization continues to., make substantial"and'material contributions to the mutual" defence and security, co-operate by communicating, from time to time, to the.North Atlantic Treaty Organization and its, member states,... while they continue to. make such contributions, atomic A information in accordance with the provisions of this Agreement, provided that the:Government of the United States of America -P determines that such co-operation will promote and will not constitute an unreasonable risk to its defence and security. ARTICLE I I . HI 1 M I P "II ••l^*^—^—^ Paralleling the undertaking of the Government of the United States of America under this Agreement7the other member, states of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization will, to the extent they .deem necessary, communicate to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, Including its military and civilian elementsj and to member states atomic information of their own origin of. the same types provided for in this Agreement- The terms and conditions governing these communications by other member states will be the Subject of aTjLbsoqKJQnt agreements, but ?;ill be the sane or . siniliir to the terms and conditions specified in this Agreement.- -3- NATO SECRET ..'. �NATO SECRET AC/228- -4- , ARTICLE III. . _ .7 The Government of the United States" of America will communicate to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, including its military and civilian elements, ahd to member states of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization requiring the atomic information in connection with their functions related to NATO missions, such atomic information as is determined by the Government of the United States,,of- America to be necessary to: (a) the. development of defence plane; (b) the training of personnel in the employment of and defence against atomic weapons and other military applications of atomic energy; . (c) the evaluation of the capabilities of potential enemies in the employment of- atomic weapons' and other military applications of atomic energy; and (d) the development of delivery systems compatible with the atomic weapons which they carry.ARTICLE IV /le Co-operation under this Agreement will be carried out by the Government of the United States of America in accordance with its applicable l a w s ^ K 2. Under this Agreement there will be no transfer by the Government of" the United States of America of atomic weapons:, ^ non-nuclear parts of atomic weapons, or non-nuclear parts of atomic weapons systems involving Restricted Data. "~ 3. The atomic information communicated by the Government of the United States of America pursuant to this Agreement shall be used exclusively for the preparation or implementation of NATO defence plans and activities and the development of delivery systems in the common interests of the North Atlantic -Treaty Organization. ARTICLE V 1. Atomic information communicated pursuant to this Agreement shall be accorded full security protection under applicable NATO regulations and procedures, agreed security arrangements, and national legislation and regulations.. In no case will the North Atlantic Treaty Organization or its member states maintain security standards for the safeguarding of atomic information less restrictive than those set forth in the pertinent NATO security regulations and other agreed security arrangements in effect on the date this Agreement comes into force, NATO .SECRET -4- �\ ^ -5--"-- NATO SECRET 7 P-' I AO/228-WP72P.. pA/. 2. The - establishment andAco-ordination of the security programme In all NATO military and civilian elements, will be ,. effected under the. authority'of the North Atlantic Council in '. conformity with procedures set forth in agreed security arrangements. 3. Atomic information communicated by the Government; of the United;States/of' America pursuant to this Agreement'will be made available through channels for communicating atomic inf ormation'now existing or "a^Amay^be^-hereaf ter agreed, 4. Atomic information communicated or exchanged-pursuant • to this Agreement shall not be communicated or exchanged by the North Atlantic Treaty Organization or persons'under its jurisdiction to any unauthorized persons or, except as provided in paragraph 5 'of. "this article, beyond the jurisdiction' of that ' Organization* " •' A ... — , 5. Unless otherwise specified by the Government of the United States of America, United States .atomic information provided to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization may be communicated by the North Atlantic Treaty Organization to Its member states as necessary to. 'carry out functions related to NATO nissiohs, providedp that dissemination of such atomic information withinsuefr •>' \ member states is limited to those specific individuals "concerned with the NATO missions for which the information is required*. Member states agree that atomic'information so "received from -•the North Atlantic Treaty Organization or otherwise pursuant to this Agreement will not be transferred to*-unauthorised - persons or beyond the jurisdiction of the recipient member state; however such information may be communicated 'to the North • •'"• Atlantic Treaty Organization or, when-authorised-by the'Government of the'United States of'America, to other member:' states Arequiring A the information for functions related to NATO missions. 7 " ••••y j • ARTICLE VI"" P ;•••; - -••' " :' 7'' 3 '"' ' ;•".<:;•...:'. Other "provisions of this Agreement notwithstanding^1' the Government of the. United States "of America may stipulate, the .• A degree;, to .'Which any'of tlie atomic information inade available* by'•',.*. it to the -North Atlantic Treaty -Organization or member 'states'--:"p;: ; • may be disseminated, may specify the categories of persons who ' •••••• may.have access to such information, and may impose such other restrictions on„ the dissemination of information as it deems necessary. A " P' �NATO SECRET l i • i /mini - -" f -' ' -6- •— . ARTICLE VII r -1 - • • /l, A Party receiving atomic information under this Agreement shall use it for the purposes specified herein only. Any inventions or discoveries resulting from posession of such information on the part of a recipient Party or persons under its jurisdiction shall be made available to the Government of the United States of America for defence purposes without charge in accordance with such arrangements—as-.may be agreed and shall be safeguarded in accordance with the provisions of Article IV of this Agreement^ 2. The application or use of any information communicated under, this Agreement shall be the responsibility of the Party receiving it; the Party communicating the information does not provide any indemnity or warranty with respect to its application or use. ARTICLE VIII ^/Nothing in this Agreement shall be considered to supersede or otherwise, affect bilateral agreements between Parties to this Agreement providing for co-operation in the exchange of atomic information^ ••-*.-• ARTICLE IX For the purposes of this Agreement: (a) "Atomic weapon" means any device utilising atomic energy, exclusive of the means for transporting or propelling the device (where such means is a separable and divisible part of the device), the principal purpose of which is for use as, or for development of, a weapon, a weapon prototype, or a weapon test device, u (b) 'LAtomic information" to be provided by the Government of the United States of America under this. Agreement means . : information which is designated "Restricted Data" or "Formerly Restricted Data" by the Government of the United States of America, . ... • ARTICLE X .. 1. This Agreement shall enter into force upon receipt by the Government of the United States of America of notification from all Parties to the North Atlantic Treaty that they are willing to be bound by the terms of the Agreement. NATO SECRET -6- �• 7 • •.".'•'• 3 -• -7~ . .7.. NATO JECRE^ --** A07228-WP72 {2e If any,other state becomes a Party to the North ' . •' ' " Atlantic Treaty no Information made -available to- the North. Atlantic-.Treaty Organization under this- Agreement will be provided... to any person who-is .a national of, or-who-is employed-by, the new Party to the North Atlantic Treaty until the new Party has notified the Government of the United States of America that it is willing to be bound by the terms of this Agreement, and upon such notification, this- Agr^^ettt*wiM««iEter into, force for the new Party^ .' -..' 3. The Government of the United States of America will •: inform /the North Atlantic7 Treaty Organization and all Parties to the North Atlantic TreatyJ of each notification, and of. the . entry into force of this Agreement.-. • ; j" 'A a P • 4, This Agreement shall remain in force until terminated by unanimous agreement or superseded by another agreement, it • p. I ... being understood, however, that termination of this Agreement as- , a whole shall not release any Party from the requirements of this Agreement to safeguard information made available pursuant to it.. ARTICLE XI Y - 3 ' Z •'.' Notwithstanding the provisions of Article Vl(4) of the j Agreement between the Parties, to the North Atlantic Treaty for. A -J:P]V Co-operation regarding Atomic Information, signed in Paris on 22nd June, 1955» the present Agreement .shall upon its entry into force supersede the above-mentioned Agreement, It being.understood however that information communicated under-that AgreementP Sy.77 ^/shall"be considered for all purposes to have been communicated under the provisions of this Agreement '(United States' text)/shall • continue to be safeguarded in accordance v/ith "the provisions," thereof, asAif these provisions were s.tiil In force.P(Unlte.dp: .-.:,.•! .•_:•-. Kingdom proposed text27* 'y : - In witness whereof .the undersigned Representatives have signed the present Agreement on behalf -of their respective ^States,: members -of the North Atlantic. Treats?- Organization, and on behalf of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, ••••-• .* Done at Paris this p ,._ ^^^A3^ °£ ' 19pniii; In the English and French languages.,-, both texts being equally authoritative, in a single original which shall be deposited in the archives of the Government *of the United States of America.. . -7- . NATO SECRET �NATO SECRET -8- " AC7^2'8^fP7Sl • The Government of the United States of America shall transmit certified copies thereof to all the signatory and acceding States, For the Kingdom of Belgium: For Canada: - For the Kingdom of Denmark: For France: For the Federal Republic of Germany: For the Kingdom of Greece: For Iceland: For Italy: For the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg: For the Kingdom of the Netherlands: For the Kingdom of Norway-: For Portugal: For Turkey: For the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland: For the United States of America: NATO SEQRET .:..._ -8- �• /.. -9-.P" NATO SECRET" g. .- '•• ANNEX A" to '••• **• AC/228-TO72-- - . .- TECHNICAL ANNEX"-TO .THE AGREEMENTpBETWEEN THE *A, PAETIE'3 . T S ' W E ^ NORTH ATLANTlg" TREATY FOR -CO-OPERATION - '...P. "REGARDING ATOMIC INFOFJ1ATION ^The provisions of this Annex implement certain of the provisions of thePAgreement^e^^OB^sff^r^^drcin^Regarding Atomic Information signed at Paris on **.»P (hereinafter referred to as the Agreement) of which this Annex forms an integrala part/J ' v •-. SEC^iM-2 Subject to the terms and conditions of the Agreement, the types of atomic information whlen the Government "of the United States of America may make available to the North Atlantic Treaty "Organization and its member states are: A. As may "be necessary for mutual defence planning', ' \ training, ..and logistical requirements, information concerning • the numbers,' locations, types, yields, arming, safing', command'"...p.. ,...*•••..-. and control, and fuzing of those atomic weapons which can be."made available for use by or in support of the North Atlantic.Treaty, > , : Organization./'''." r -•"• ""''. .-''••' •'' "i.- ' '"•P."''--,.- >, •'""-, ,P A . ~B0i f Effects to be expected'or resulting from the '.-" . -Pj^pP tp'; detonation of atomic weapons.>: '" 3-. Y73:YYY Y: 0, Response of structures, equipment, communications' and 5 -j personnel to the effects of atomic-weapons, including damage or casualty criteria. •-.-., ;. . a . - •-- i *,« • D. Methods and procedures for analyses relating tothe 7 \7\. effeets of atomic weapons.' "".''" . E, Information on the capabilities of potential enemy, nations for atomic warfare, Ft Information on atomic weapons and atomic:weapons systems required for attainment of delivery capability with specified atomic weapons which can be made available for use by or in support of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, including information required for evaluation of atomic weapons systems, to, determine NATO requirements and strategy. G.. Information regarding delivery systems," including tactics and techniques and duties of maintenance, assembly., delivery and launch crews required for -attainment of delivery capability with specified atomic weapons. -9--PA-" • NATO SECRET �NATO SECRET OTJEX -. -10- A_to AC2228£WP22 H» To the extent that they will influence NATO planning, the results to be expected from the strategic air offensive. I, Information required for attainment of compatibility of specified atomic weapons with specified delivery vehicles, J. Safety features ;o*f**epe,elvfi-edF*;atomic weapons and of the operational systems associated 'with such weapons and information necessary and appropriate for salvage and recovery operations incident to a weapons accident. K. Information required in planning for and training of personnel in the employment of and defence against atomic weapons and including information concerning: La 1. Military uses of isotopes for medical purposes.. 2. Defence against radiological warfare. Information regarding civil defence against atomic a t t a c k s . ' • • ' "I ' • • ' ' • ' M. Other information as may be determined by appropriateUnited States Authorities to be necessary for support of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization and transferable under provisions of the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended, and the Agreement* SECTION II No information on other military applications of atomic energy, military reactors, or naval nuclear propulsion, plants, will be communicated under the Agreement. For the Kingdom of Belgium: : For Canada: For the Kingdom of Denmark: For France: For the Federal Republic of Germany: For the Kingdom of Greece: For Iceland: For Italy: For the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg: NATO SECRET . . r lO r �V"V / -11- NATO SECRET ATO3TT"to" Ip7_228rgg?2' For the Kingdom of 'the-'N-etherlands:' lor the Kingdom of Norway: For Portugal: For Turkey: " -. "' 'A For the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland: For the United States of America: -11- NATO SECRET 000235 �7*7 -13 NATO _OONFIDENTIA.L ANfgXJB j o ~ AC?228-WP, SECURITY ANNEX _TOJPHE_ AGREEMENJ_BEWI^EN_THE_ PARTIESlTCMI^Q.™. ATLA^'TICf TREATY jOR _COZOPERATION " REG;4RDING"ATOMIC INFORMATION This Annex sets forth the security measures which the North Atlantic Treaty 0rgan"ihza'1^oS^M(ffeCK,ewinember states shall apply to safeguard atomic information made available by the Government of the United States of America to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization and Its member states pursuant to the Agreement for Co-operation Regarding Atomic Information signed at Paris on *»••«•*••«(referred to hereinafter as "the Agreement") of which this Annex is an integral part* .In the event a member of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization other than the Government of the United States of America makes atomic information available pursuant to Article II of the Agreement, such information shall be safeguarded by security measures no less restrictive than those set forth in this Annex. SECTION^! GENERAL ' • A» NATO security regulations, no less restrictive than those which are presently set forth in C-M(55)15(Final) and the Confidential Supplement of 1st January, 1961, thereto, as well as the security measures specified in this Annex, shall be applied by'NATO military and civilian elements and by.member states : to atomic information communicated pursuant to the Agreement. B, The Security programme as implemented by all NATO military and civilian elements and by member states receiving atomic information pursuant to the Agreement shall.provide fully for carrying out the security requirements laid down in this Annex. C, The Secretary General, acting in the name of the North Atlantic Council and under its authority, shall be responsible for supervising the application of the NATO Security programme for the protection of atomic information under the Agreement. He will ascertain by means of the procedures set forth in Section X of this Annex that all measures required by the NATO Security programme are taken in-NATO civil and military elements and national civil and military elements to protect the information exchanged under the Agreement. D» " No individual shall be entitled to access to atomic information solely by virtue of rank, appointment, or security clearance. -13- NATO CONFIDENTIAL �NATO;CONFIDENTIAL -14- A M E X " PB to AC/T2r8-V/P72~ E, Access to atomic information made available to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization shall be limited to nationals of states, members of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization who have been greated security clearances in accordance with Section II of this Annex and whose responsibilities require access to the information. F. Access to atomic information made available to a member state pursuant to the Agreement shall be limited to its nationals who have been granted security clearances in accordance .with Section II of this Annex and whose duties require access in order that the member state can fulfill its responsibilities and commitments to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, SECTION II PERSONNEL SECURITY A, No individual shall be granted a security clearance for access to atomic information unless it is determined that such clearance will not endanger the security of the Forth Atlantic Treaty Organisation or the national security of the member states of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. B, Prior to affording access to atomic information, the determination of eligibility (decision'to grant security clearance) for each individual to be afforded such access shall be made by a responsible authoritiy of the government of the • • individual concerned, ' C, The decision as to whether the granting of a security clearance is clearly consistent with the interests of security shall be a determination based on all available information. Prior to'this determination, an investigation shall be conducted by a responsible government authority and the information developed shall be reviewed in the light of the principal types of derogatory information which create a question as to an individual's eligibility foi- security clearance, as these are set forth in Section III of the Confidential Supplement of 1st January, 1961, to C-M(55)l5(Final). D„ The minimum scope and extent of the investigation shall be in accordance with the standards set out in Section II of the Confidential Supplement to C-M(55)l5(Final).,. except that "-" a background investigation shall be required for clearance for access to atomic information classified Secret for individuals other than members of the armed forces or civilian personnel of the military establishments of the member states. �"V* . -15-"-•"' NATO CONFIDENTIAL . ANtfExPBjto * V .-:•>"'' AC/228-WP72 " -''" . . E. - Each establishment handling-atomic information shall maintain- an appropriate record of the clearance of individuals authorised to have access to such information at that:establishment. Each clearance, shall be reviewed, as the occasion demands, to insure that it conforms with the current standards applicable, to the individual's employm.ent-,-vand..>.,sha.ll-.be re-examined as a matter of priority when information is received which indicates' that continued employment involving access to atomic information may no longer be consistent-with the interests of security, F* Effective liaison shall be maintained in each- state between the national agencies responsible for national security and the authority responsible for making clearance determinations to assure prompt notification of information with derogatory implications developed subsequent to .the grant of security clearance, " • - , . . . SECTION. Ill .PHYSICAL SECURITY • . • P 7. ", '-- ' A. Atomic information shall be protected physically ... •' against espionage,- sabotage, unauthorised access or any -other P. hostile activity. Such protection shall be commensurate with, the importance of the -security interest-involved.. ,,B„ Programmes for physical security-of atomic information sliall be established so as to assure:' -10 . Proper protection of atomic information on hand for immediate use, in storage- or \. . in transit,, .. ' . 2. - The establishment of security areas, with. . • controlled access, when deemed, necessary A by reason of the sensitivity, character, volume.and use of the classified atomic information,; and the character and location. of the building or buildings involved, '7. 3« A. system of controlled access which shall • embody procedures for a•competent, authority - . to authorise access, accurate methods of . personnel identification Pand accountability for identification media; and a means "''.'..' , • •-••..-•- of enforcing limitations on movement within, : and access to, security areas. • PA C, The provisions of paragraph B above will be in addition to the procedures set forth in Section IV of C-M(55)l5(Final). �NATO CONFIDENTIAL ANNEX'B to -16- SECTION IV CONTROL OF ATOMIC•INFORMATION A, Information control programmes shall be maintained which will have for their basic -purposes-f^'*-;—-~ • 1, Control of access. .2. Ready accountability commensurate with the degree of sensitivity. 3» Destruction when no longer needed. B, Security classifications applied by the Government of the United States of America to atomic information communicated under the Agreement shall be observed at all times; regrading or declassification may be done only with the approval of the Government of the United States of America. C, Documents containing United States atomic information communicated under the Agreement shall bear NATO markings and a security classification equivalent to that assigned by the Government of the United States of America, followed by the word ..i.«.(l). In addition, the following marking shall be entered on the document in the language of the documents "This document contains United-States atomic information (Restricted Data or Formerly Restricted Data) .made available pursuant to the NATO Agreement for Go-operation Regarding Atomic Information signed .......(date) ....... - and will be.safeguarded accordingly." D, Accountability records shall be maintained for all Top Secret and Secret documents, and for all documents on which special limitations have been placed in accordance with Article V of the Agreement. These records shall show the identity of all recipients of documents on which special limitations have been placed /and shall note the use made of information contained therein^/' (1) New code word to be agreed NATO CONFIDENTIAL • -16- �J -17- NATO. CONFIDENTIAL ANNEX B to AC/228-WP72 E. Reproductions, including extracts and translations, of documents containing United States atomic information bearing the markings.specified in paragraph 0. above may be made under the follov/ing. rules: /le Documents classified Secret and- Top Secret .. . ..." may b'e'reproduced only with- the prior' - approval of the Government of the United States A •'• - ofr'America. ^ ^ ^ T ^ W d M r n t T shall bear a • Suitable-notation to this effect.. In: "emergencies when prior approval cannot be . •-p obtained in time, this rule: may be waived, but the Government of the'United States of America • shall be so inf ormed- by the most .expeditious m.e'ansJL7'' •' :-L- -2. -' Documents classified Confidential may be A reproduced only as necessary to. meet current requirements.. • 3. Reproductions, including extracts and trans-" .7 . P lations, shall bear all security markings 1 A- -A-' -1 (including athe marking described in paragraph C) \'"Y. '" ' found on the original document^ and- shall be .- - .1: A-••••-"•••-••-" - -'- placed under the accountability controls ..: •• •applied to the original document. -Where, A - .. ."-:•• --'•'; A paragraphs, bear separate classifications, the a . . security classification of documents containing •: .. extracted atomic information shall bear the classification of the-paragraph-with the ••-' -.'-'•'"'.•• "highest .classification from which extracts-were ••taken ahd where appropriate the marking • •'' •"• "A*v :'- • • specif led., i n paragraph C, Accountability controls -"•:.•---,• - -P -'. for.;extract.ed- atomic information shall be asP provided in paragraph D of this eection., .1:7 Further, such special limitations as"may have been'.placed on the originalPdocument shall ! .apply ---"- , - -. to^documents, containing the-extracts..'AA A . P F. Documents prepared- to record atomic. inf ormation ....,- "A ,• received under the Agreement by oral or visual means shall bear the -markings" specified in paragraph 0 above and -shall'be -••-••:•' subject to the rules for accountability and control applicable to the level of classification involved. -17- NATO CONFIDENTIAL �NATO CONFIDENTIAL -18- AMfKTF to i m i m i • • » • • H M J j T - i r n i r i l ,r • — - * ] * . . . . . AC/22S^WP72 SECTION V CHANNELS OF TPJiNSMISSION . Communications by the Government of the United States of America of atomic information under the Agreement, including oral and visual communication, shall be through channels now existing or as may be hereafter agreed. To assist the Secretary General in the.'dTschai'ge'^of ''his security responsibilities under paragraph C of Section I of the present Annex, the Government of the United States of America shall provide the Secretary General with sufficient information to identify each written communication of atomic information by the Government of the United States of /unerica and each communication authorised by the Government of the United States of America under the AgreementP This Information will also be sent to the Standing Group for all communications made to military elements * SECTION VI REPORTS^ p. A. Each member state and NATO military and civilian element which receives United States atomic information under the Agreement shall submit by 31st March of each year, utilising channels now existing or as may be hereafter agreed, through the Secretary General to the Government of the United States of America a report containing the following: 1. A list of all atomic documents received from the Government'of the United States of America during the twelve . months ending 31st December of the previous year, 2. A record of the distribution /and use/ of the documents listed in paragraph 1 above, and 3. A certification that a physical muster has been made of all atomic.documents for which the member states or NATO military or civilian element is accountable under the Agreement. The certification shall include a list of all documents unaccounted for, with a statement of the results of the . investigation of the loss and the corrective action taken to prevent a recurrence, B. If United States atomic information communicated under the Agreement is compromised by loss of documents or any other means, an immediate report including all pertinent information concerning the compromise shall be made, utilising channels now existing or as may be hereafter agreed, to the Secretary General •and the Government of the United States of America. �-19* y SECTION .V.I-I. SECURITY EDUCATION NATO .CONFIDENTIAL ANNEX~B»,to >= y'x ,:.. L " "'"!"'. *. A . Member states and NATO military and Civilian elements . receiving information under the Agreement shall maintain an A adequate programme, to assufe^'tE^lf^ll^inaividuals who are authorised-access to-atomic information are informed of their responsibilities to safeguard that, information. The.programme shall" include a' specific initial-indoctrination- and orientation, periodic re-emphasis of individual responsibilities and a termination interview stressing,,the continuing responsibilities for protectionprof atomic-information, • A . , --.-•." SECTION VIII SECURITY-OF CLASSIFIED CONTRACTS .'..-..' . -: '.';..''.'.'..•: ,' '\- 7 ./'".' 7. ., ... Every classified contract, sub-contract, consultant agreement or other arrangement entered into.by Parties to the = Agreement," the performance of which involves access to atomic information exchanged, under the Agreement, shall contain, appropriate.provisions"imposing obligations .'on .the private. A: '••'•• partiesinvolved to abide by the security arrangements, set forth P.in this .-Annex, A'.'.-A. -•,. . 7 ;.•... -: -,--.,... yY: ,':.. ..A "'"' SECTION IX "' CONTINUING.' RIEVIEW . OF • SECURITY SYSTEM '. ..." ..."- '""P • -•"•"•'".•.: ""'V-V • YY77Y A'"'"'" 3-: '•:- A*.. It-is recognised that effective and prompt - 'i":7' ;( implementation of security policies can be materially advanced71 A through" reciprocal visits of security personnel, , It.is agreed A • ._... to continue a thorough exchange of views relative to security policies:,? standards and procedures and to, permit -United States'. 1 security -vSro-rk.ihg_groups oto-examine an<l__view", at 'first hand the A \ procedures-and practices'of the.agencies of the North Y 7.Y Atlantic Treaty. Organization and of the. agencies ' of member" Y'l states responsible - for.the protection'of' documents and.informationcommunicated under ; the. Agreement-^, such; visits to be undertaken- "; • with a .view to."achieving an understanding of adequacy and 771 reasonable comparability of the respective security systems. " AB* A. The Secretary'General, and the Standing - Group -..."., , in the case pf visits tp military elements, will be informed _" of these visits and reports.setting forth- pertinent findings 1 •of. the United, States .working groups., will be furnished to t h e m . " following each-visit. . All visits to national'elements will.be carried out in co-operation with the national security authorities of the states concerned. -19- -"• NATO CONFIDENTIAL �p-'ATO CONFIDENTIAL INNEX B"*to -20- 107228^1572 SECTION X < — — i — • « i I I I I D i m PECURITY INSPECTIONS A, Comprehensive security inspection of all NATO military and civilian elements and member nations which have received atomic information under the"^A^'TSe2l§nt"1^shall be made regularly, Put not.less often than once every twelve, months, in accordance with the criteria set forth in Section I, paragraph A of this Annex. These inspections shall"be made by the NATO agencies having responsibility for the application of the NATO Security programme, using qualified personnel. The Council may, -as it considers necessary or desirable, direct special inspections to be made and designate ad hoc inspection teams composed of personnel from NATO civilian and military agencies or other qualified personnel. Visits to military and civilian elements of member states will be co-ordinated with the appropriate national authorities. ..-'-.'. B, All phases of the Security programme shall be examined and within thirty days.after the completion of the inspection, a written report that shall include a .list of any deficiencies found in the:application of the security regulations will be sent to the Secretary General. C, Copies of these inspection reports shall be.made available by the Secretary General to the United States pursuant to the Agreement and, consistent with other provisions thereof and as may be appropriate, to the installation inspected, the national security authority concerned, and the military headquarters. D, Within thirty days after receipt of the Inspection report, the appropriate authorities of the NATO or national element inspected shall forward to the Secretary General a report of action taken to correct all deficiencies listed in the inspection report. After reviewing the inspection reports and the reports of corrective action taken, the Secretary"General, acting on behalf of the Council, shall, as appropriate, draw the attention of the national authorities, the Standing Group or the civilian element concerned to whatever further action may be required, to meet NATO security criteria and the provisions of this Agreement, Copies of the reports of corrective action as well as copies of any comments forthcoming from the Secretary General in accordance with this paragraph shall be distributed in the same manner as provided in paragraph C of this Section for the inspection reports. NATO CONFIDENTIAL -20- �-21- • NATO CONFIDEKTIALPg-' CA AteXjTto" *Y? ACZ?28-.WP7,?, •"'*'"" E. In the event that a problem regarding corrective action arising fr5n a security inspection,remains, unresolved after the application of procedures set forth in paragraph D of this Annex, the Secretary General shall bring the matter to the attention1 of the Council with a recommendation that an ad hoc Inspection team be designated to investigate the problem and report to the Council, v/hich will thereupon take appropria^te^actipn.: ... For the Kingdom of Belgium: For Canada: .-. ,-, For the Kingdom of Denmark: • For France: '•••-,- For the Federal Republic of "Germany: • For the Kingdom of Greece: t For Iceland: For Italy: '• - '••....- For the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg: a. '-,- •-.,_. .. •• •• For the Kingdom of the Netherlands: For the" Kingdom of Norway:" For Portugal: A;. For Turkey: For the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland: ' ' . For the United States of America: ••' •• • NATO CONFIDENTIAL � Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Identifier An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context CDNW04967 Title A name given to the resource NATO Document AC/228-WP/2 Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 23-Apr-64 Source A related resource from which the described resource is derived NATO Agreement for Cooperation Regarding Atomic Information, RG24-B-1, vol. 21471, CSC 2108-1-AC-228, Library and Archives Canada (LAC). Creator An entity primarily responsible for making the resource Department of National Defence Rights Information about rights held in and over the resource Canadian Crown Subject The topic of the resource NATO, nuclear weapons Description An account of the resource Working Group on a Draft Agreement for Co-Operation Regarding Atomic Information (Second Revision of Draft Agreement) Publisher An entity responsible for making the resource available Canada Declassified Type The nature or genre of the resource Text Format The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource PDF Language A language of the resource en